Sometimes, when I’m up at 3:00 am (which I often am) and not listening to mediocre podcast appearances by 2028 hopefuls (which I often am), I do the New York Times crossword puzzle.

The thematic lynchpin for Thursday’s puzzle – spoiler alert! – was the Billie Eilish song, “What Was I Made For?” which is a certified banger (insofar as hauntingly beautiful ballads from the Barbie movie can be bangers). It is also one of those songs that gets stuck in my head on repeat, and I literally only know those five words.

So this is what was happening in my brain in the wee hours of the morning yesterday as I attempted to re-listen to all the speeches by 2028ers at the recent What’s Next? conference in Denver – just an unwitting PETE BUTTIGIEG/Billie Eilish mash-up, followed by JOSH SHAPIRO ft. Billie, and on and on.

As maddening as this experience was, at some point it dawned on me that this was, in fact, a fitting soundtrack for the 2028 cattle call.

See, the many White House auditionees ably answered the summit’s titular question – what’s next must be delivering on affordability and accountability – but a presidential candidacy must answer the more existential question. It must have a deeper purpose; a more visceral rationale. What were you made for?

On this front, two speeches really stood out to me – and neither came from a 2028 frontrunner.

The first came from IA Gov.-elect Rob Sand, who is truly a unique political talent. When you learn that he starts each of his 100 annual town halls by having attendees of opposing parties clap for one another, and then sing ‘America the Beautiful’ together, you will surely roll your eyes. But please, just watch this speech. And then watch the exchange that the speech recounts – where Sand hands the mic to his MAGA troll to ask him questions – and listen to his answers. You will not be left wondering what Rob Sand’s vision for America is, but rather when we can realize it.

And then there is Sen. Andy Kim (D-NJ), who moved me to tears as he described the inhumanity and financial ruin of trying to care for his father – a man who dedicated his life to curing Alzheimer’s and is now incapacitated by it – and implored us to be caregivers for an ailing country that has similarly forgotten who we are. Nestled in this prayer was a stirring pitch for two signature bills designed with intentionality – substantively, procedurally, and politically – to create a real path to universal health care and afford families the freedom and dignity we deserve.

It is unlikely that Rob Sand or Andy Kim will be our nominee in 2028. But these are two guys who know what they’re made for.

Many candidates are still lacking that foundational why. And you can’t run for president just because that’s what’s next.

Crosstabs

There have been a bunch of high-quality polls of the 2028 Democratic primary in the last couple weeks – most of which included demographic crosstabs – so I thought I’d aggregate them for you sickos.

We are still in the first inning, but for now, a clear top five has taken shape, with JON OSSOFF rocketing up the leaderboard, joined by KAMALA, AOC, PETE, & GAVIN.

Notably, the top three candidates are also the only ones listed who seem truly undecided about running.

In prediction markets, OSSOFF is now the favorite by a wide margin. And he also dominated the Crooked Con straw poll, underscoring his support with the hyper-engaged Democratic base.

Quick Hits

It’s been a minute and a ton is happening, so let me first start with some trends, and then a slightly-less-exhaustive-than-usual selection of quick hits I found notable…

WHAT’S TRENDING 📈

  • Books. 📈 PETE BUTTIGIEG’s new book NEXT will come out on Jan. 26, followed by the release of WES MOORE’s Repair: Healing a Divided Nation on Mar. 9. They’ll join HARRIS, SHAPIRO, NEWSOM, BOOKER, MURPHY, WARNOCK, & BESHEAR as recently published book authors. Book fever is so rampant – and AOC drives so much attention – that the Examiner published a standalone report that she is not writing a book. 🚨 NEWS: Area Woman Not Writing Book.

  • Begging. 📈 There are now at least six outside efforts begging 2028ers to run, with varying degrees of affiliation with said candidate. The most recent (and notable) is Team Pete PAC, which is co-led by BUTTIGIEG’s former chief of staff at DOT and the campaign manager for his 2017 DNC Chair bid, per Politico’s Adam Wren.

  • Brokers. 📈 I talked to NBC News’s Sasha Marquez about the new God-queen of SC, Annie Andrews, noted Michigan Man Abdul El-Sayed, and all the other new early state power brokers. The Hill and Politico also did versions of this story, and the courting is very much already underway.

  • Bashes. 📈 Here is a surely incomplete snapshot of recent cattle calls, most of which should now be linked in the Big Beautiful Tracker:

  • ELISSA SLOTKIN endorsed Chris Van Hollen for Senate Majority Leader, reiterating her calls for generational change and bold leadership. CVH’s other endorsers are all Bernie-aligned. MARK KELLY & RUBEN GALLEGO have endorsed Schumer, while other 2028ers have remained uncommitted.

    • SLOTKIN also made clear she’s seriously considering running, and remains locked in an escalating showdown with Trump’s DOJ over her comments about holding criminal actors in the admin accountable.

  • GAVIN NEWSOM said he’d decide in “early January” whether to mount a 2028 bid. (So much for deferring to KAMALA, I guess!) The comment came amid an international tour that included stops at COP31 in Turkey and a visit to Ukraine.

  • MARK KELLY brought back his old Senate campaign manager, Emma Brown, to serve as a top political aide as he “finalize[s] a decision about 2028,” Politico’s Lisa Kashinsky scooped.

    • KELLY and actress Olivia Munn teamed up for a media tour around new legislation to make early breast cancer risk assessments more accessible and routine.

  • AOC did her first Fox News hit in six years, appearing with Paris Hilton and Rep. Laurel Lee (R-FL) in support of their bipartisan bill to crack down on nonconsensual sexually explicit deepfakes.

    • We talked about AOC’s performance (and a bunch of other 2028 stuff) on the latest episode of Nobody Knows Anything.

  • PETE BUTTIGIEG got some good ink from both the NYT’s Jess Biddeford and CNN’s Isaac Dovere for his big swings in stretch races in the midterms, and spoke to Mother Jones’s Pema Levy about his push for sweeping structural reforms to our democracy.

  • WES MOORE’s team has been punching back at critics amid a fresh round of scrutiny on the details of his military service.

    • MOORE penned a USA Today op-ed celebrating the election of more Black governors this month than in the previous 250+ years of American history.

  • RAHM EMANUEL skipped the What’s Next confab in Denver – and spent two days next door in the early state of New Mexico instead, meeting with Gov.-elect Deb Haaland, among other stops.

  • MITCH LANDRIEU made clear he’s still actively considering a presidential bid.

  • BRAD CARSON – a former Oklahoma Rep. turned AI safety champion – is likely to run for president, Politico’s Calder McHugh reports.

  • Axios’s Holly Otterbein scooped that Zohran Mamdani is angling to be a progressive kingmaker in 2028 if AOC doesn’t run, meeting with labor leaders like UAW’s Shawn Fain, AFA-CWA’s Sara Nelson, and IUPAT’s Jimmy Williams Jr.

  • A few other big picture stories worth reading…